Why Audits Happen

Exploring Audit Triggers: Understanding Their Importance for Transparency and Trust



Audits are essential for a multitude of reasons, chief among them being regulatory compliance, the validation of internal controls, and the accuracy of financial statements. They ensure that an organization is adhering to relevant laws and regulations, reducing the risk of legal repercussions and financial penalties. Audits also assess the efficacy of internal controls, thereby ensuring that resources are used efficiently and securely, and that financial data is reliable. Moreover, by providing an independent review of financial statements, audits boost transparency and bolster stakeholder confidence in the organization's financial health and integrity.

Regulatory Compliance

Regulatory compliance refers to the adherence to laws, regulations, guidelines, and specifications relevant to an organization's business processes and operations. This involves not just following the rules set forth by governmental bodies but also meeting industry-specific standards and codes of practice. Compliance ensures that organizations operate ethically and responsibly, mitigating risks associated with legal liabilities, sanctions, and reputational damage. It is a dynamic and ongoing process that requires regular monitoring and auditing to adapt to evolving laws and standards. Failure to maintain regulatory compliance can result in legal penalties, loss of licensure, and could adversely impact an organization's reputation and financial standing.

Regulatory compliance audits can be triggered by various circumstances, including but not limited to:

1. Scheduled Reviews: Many industries have regular, mandated audit cycles, often annually or bi-annually, as part of standard regulatory oversight.

2. Changes in Legislation: When laws or regulations change, organizations may be required to undergo an audit to demonstrate new compliance measures.

3. Incident Response: Any significant incident, like a data breach, accident, or other event that could potentially violate regulations, often triggers a compliance audit.

4. Mergers and Acquisitions: When one company acquires another, or two companies merge, a compliance audit is usually required to ensure that the new entity is fully compliant with all relevant laws and regulations.

5. Stakeholder Request: Shareholders, board members, or financial institutions involved with the organization might call for an audit, particularly if there are concerns about compliance.

6. Whistleblower Reports: If an employee or other insider reports non-compliance or other irregularities, it often triggers an immediate audit.

7. Random Selection: Some regulatory bodies perform random audits as a part of their oversight duties to ensure companies remain compliant.

8. Licensing Requirements: In certain industries, the act of renewing a license to operate may also require a compliance audit.

9. Post-Litigation: After settling a case or legal issue, organizations often have to undergo an audit to ensure that they are now in compliance with the law.

Real World Examples:

1. Scheduled Reviews: Publicly traded companies in the U.S. are regularly audited for compliance with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX), which mandates protections against fraud in financial reporting.

2. Changes in Legislation: When the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) was introduced in the EU, companies doing business in Europe underwent audits to ensure their data handling practices were compliant.

3. Incident Response: After the Equifax data breach in 2017, the company faced multiple compliance audits related to cybersecurity standards and data protection laws.

4. Mergers and Acquisitions: When Disney acquired 21st Century Fox, compliance audits were performed to ensure both companies met all anti-trust and industry regulations.

5. Stakeholder Request: After allegations of emissions cheating surfaced against Volkswagen, shareholders and regulators demanded compliance audits regarding environmental standards.

6. Whistleblower Reports: Enron's collapse was preceded by internal whistleblower reports that eventually led to extensive audits and revealed a lack of compliance with accounting regulations.

7. Random Selection: The U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) performs random audits of workplaces to ensure compliance with safety standards.

8. Licensing Requirements: Pharmaceutical companies like Pfizer or Moderna must undergo compliance audits to renew their Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP) licenses.

9. Post-Litigation: Companies found guilty of illegal dumping of waste often have to undergo environmental compliance audits as part of their settlement agreements.

Internal Controls

Internal controls are not typically "triggered" in the way that an audit might be; rather, they are generally designed to be ongoing processes or procedures that are continuously active within an organization. However, the implementation or enhancement of internal controls can be prompted by various events or conditions:

1. Startup Phase: When a company is newly established, internal controls are implemented to ensure the business starts on a sound footing.

2. Organizational Growth: Expanding companies often have to scale or modify their internal controls to accommodate new employees, departments, or lines of business.

3. New Legislation or Regulations: Changes in laws or industry regulations may require companies to implement new internal controls or revise existing ones.

4. Internal Audits: Findings from periodic internal audits can lead to the enhancement or implementation of new internal controls.

5. External Audits: Feedback or findings from an external audit can prompt a review and potential overhaul of existing internal controls.

6. Incidents of Fraud or Error: Discovery of fraudulent activities or significant errors within the organization often leads to immediate reassessment and strengthening of internal controls.

7. Technological Changes: The adoption of new technologies or systems often necessitates the update or addition of internal controls related to data security and integrity.

8. Management Reviews: Regular management reviews can identify areas where internal controls are lacking or could be strengthened.

9. Stakeholder Pressure: Investors or board members demanding better governance can lead to a comprehensive review and improvement of internal controls.

10. Financial Restatements: If a company has to restate its financials due to errors or omissions, this usually leads to a re-evaluation of related internal controls.

11. Mergers and Acquisitions: Merging with or acquiring another company often requires a re-evaluation of internal controls to integrate the two organizations effectively.

12. Litigation or Legal Actions: Any form of legal scrutiny or pending action against the company can necessitate an immediate review of internal controls, especially those related to compliance and reporting.

Real World Examples:

1. Startup Phase: When tech startup Dropbox began its operations, it implemented internal controls for data security and financial reporting to establish trust with users and investors.

2. Organizational Growth: As Amazon expanded its retail operations and entered new markets like streaming services and cloud computing, it had to adapt its internal controls to manage complexities and comply with various regulations.

3. New Legislation or Regulations: When GDPR was enacted in the European Union, companies like Google had to implement new data protection controls to comply with privacy requirements.

4. Internal Audits: After an internal audit, Microsoft implemented additional internal controls to further secure its intellectual property and trade secrets.

5. External Audits: Following an external audit, JP Morgan Chase strengthened its internal controls related to risk management after the "London Whale" trading scandal exposed vulnerabilities.

6. Incidents of Fraud or Error: After the Wells Fargo scandal involving the unauthorized opening of customer accounts, the bank was forced to review and strengthen its internal controls related to sales practices and customer authorization.

7. Technological Changes: With the adoption of cloud-based services, Salesforce implemented new internal controls to ensure data security and compliance with financial reporting standards.

8. Management Reviews: After an internal management review, Coca-Cola enhanced its internal controls for overseas operations to better comply with anti-corruption and fair trade practices.

9. Stakeholder Pressure: Under pressure from shareholders, Tesla has undergone multiple rounds of revising its internal controls, particularly those related to financial disclosures and executive conduct.

10. Financial Restatements: After having to restate earnings due to accounting errors, General Electric (GE) underwent a significant overhaul of its internal financial controls.

11. Mergers and Acquisitions: When Disney acquired 21st Century Fox, it had to integrate and align internal controls across the two organizations, focusing on areas like financial reporting and compliance.

12. Litigation or Legal Actions: Pharmaceutical company Johnson & Johnson reviewed and updated its quality control measures as internal controls after facing lawsuits related to product safety.

Financial Statement Accuracy

Financial statement accuracy audits are formal examinations conducted by external auditors to verify the accuracy, completeness, and compliance of an organization's financial statements with applicable accounting standards and regulations. These audits provide an independent opinion on whether the financial statements present a true and fair view of the company's financial position, results of operations, and cash flows for a specific period.

The process involves a detailed review of a company's accounting records, internal controls, and other evidence that supports the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. Techniques such as sampling, analytical procedures, and substantive tests are commonly used. The auditors assess the risk of material misstatement due to fraud or error and design their audit procedures accordingly.

The primary aim is to provide assurance to stakeholders, including shareholders, creditors, and regulators, that the financial statements can be relied upon for making informed decisions. An audit of financial statement accuracy helps instill confidence in the marketplace, ensures compliance with statutory requirements, and can even reveal areas for operational improvement within the organization.

Financial statement accuracy audits are commonly triggered by the following circumstances:

1. Regularly Scheduled Audits: Many jurisdictions require publicly traded companies to undergo annual audits as part of their regulatory obligations.

2. Funding Rounds or IPOs: Companies seeking external funding or preparing for an Initial Public Offering (IPO) often need to provide audited financial statements to potential investors.

3. Bank Loan Applications: Financial institutions frequently require audited financial statements from companies applying for significant loans or credit lines.

4. Mergers and Acquisitions: Both parties usually require audited financial statements as part of the due diligence process before finalizing a merger or acquisition.

5. Change in Ownership or Management: Significant changes in the ownership or executive management team can prompt an audit to ensure financial transparency.

6. Regulatory or Compliance Requirements: Changes in laws or regulations might necessitate an audit to verify compliance with new financial reporting standards.

7. Stakeholder Demand: Shareholders, board members, or partners may request an audit for a variety of reasons, such as suspicions of fraud or mismanagement.

8. Contractual Obligations: Some business contracts, including joint ventures or long-term supplier agreements, may require periodic audits as part of the contract terms.

9. Random Selection: In some jurisdictions or sectors, organizations may be randomly selected for audits by regulatory bodies to ensure overall compliance with financial reporting standards.

10. Legal Proceedings: In case of legal disputes or claims against a company, audited financial statements might be demanded as evidence in court.

11. Bankruptcy or Restructuring: When a company goes through a bankruptcy process or a major restructuring, audited financial statements are often required to assess the financial health of the organization and guide the process.

12. End of Business Lifecycle: If a company is winding down or dissolving, a final audit may be required to ensure all financial matters are settled appropriately.

In summary, audits are an essential component for safeguarding the financial health and integrity of your organization. They serve as a valuable tool for improving internal controls, uncovering operational inefficiencies, and building stakeholder trust. We believe that audits should do more than just meet compliance standards; they should add value to your organization by paving the way for long-term sustainability and success. If you are facing an audit, talk to us to see how we can help you maintain compliance and financial health.


Interested in learning more?
Leave your contact information below and we will reach out to you ASAP.
Check Mark
Sent ⁠— You will hear back from us soon!
Something went wrong, refresh and try sending again.
By submitting this inquiry, I agree to Starkmont Financial’s Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.